Seeing a critic in your dream means you are seeking guidance or direction in certain areas of your life. It indicates that you want to break free from negative influences. The critic symbolizes the part of you that can distinguish between right and wrong and can help you make the best decisions. This dream urges you to become more aware of the people around you and to evaluate their impact on your life.
From Imam Muhammad Ibn Seerin's Dictionary of Dreams According to Islamic Inner Traditions â entry "Critic" (page 102).
In a dream, a critic represents guidance and ridding oneself of evil companions. A critic in a dream also represents a connoisseur or one who knows what is best or someone who can discern between true and false. If he is a religious person in the dream, it means that he will chose the best of specialties and the most exalted of knowledge, that is learning and understanding God's religion. If he is a worldly man in the dream, it means that he will chose the most comfortable and pleasureful type of lifestyle. If he is a ruler in the dream, it means that he will chose the highest authority.
Note: Islamic dream interpretation depends on the dreamer's circumstances and state. This is a general guide drawn directly from the source book.